About That One Time... Film News Special Features

About That One Time a 12-Year-Old Kid Shamed Wes Craven Into Directing Scream

Wes Craven died yesterday, on the losing end of a battle against brain cancer.  He was 76.  I’ve previously written all about his tortured history with the Nightmare on Elm Street franchise.  However, there’s a funny story about how he ended up directing the first Scream movie I want to share with you.

When Dimension Films won the bidding war over Kevin Williamson’s spec script Scary Movie (later renamed Scream), the first person on their list of preferred directors was Nightmare on Elm Street genius Wes Craven. He was the perfect choice because more so than any other master of the horror genre he seemed most likely to be able to deliver the inherent thrills of a slasher movie without diluting the wit and ingenuity of Williamson’s script. That kind of thing is easier said than done because a self-referential, meta-horror comedy like Scream could have easily fall apart in anyone else’s hands much in the way the meta-action comedy Last Action Hero never quite worked despite having the man who made Die Hard, John McTiernan, behind the camera. You can’t simply hire a practitioner of the genre your film is mocking; you have to hire a practitioner who truly gets the joke and loves the script. For Dimension, it was Craven or bust.

Funny thing about that, though. Craven turned them down. Repeatedly.

Craven had tested the limits of what the MPAA would allow in a horror movie with Last House on the Left and thus gave the rest of the genre a yardstick to go by throughout the 1970s. He saved the slasher sub-genre from itself with Nightmare on Elm Street in the 1980s. Scream was his opportunity to make it three straight decades in a row directing a monumentally influential horror movie. However, by the mid-90s Craven longed for more. Seemingly destined to be shackled to the horror genre forever, he fought off boredom by continually stretching his legs, expanding the zombie genre into something closer to non-fiction in The Serpent and the Rainbow (1988), exploring class warfare and racial injustice in The People Under The Stairs (1991), taking a deep step back from Nightmare on Elm Street in his own meta-classic Wes Craven’s New Nightmare (1994) and trying for something with a comedic edge in Eddie Murphy’s Vampire in Brooklyn (1995).

But New Nightmare and Vampire in Brooklyn both bombed, and suddenly Dimension was asking Craven to direct a self-aware horror comedy, as if someone had come along and combined New Nightmare and Vampire into one movie. He could be forgiven for not being interested. When he passed, he told the producers he just didn’t want to make another slasher movie.

Scream Wes CravenLooking back on it for The Biography Channel’s Inside Story: Scream, Craven admitted, “I think the reason I passed on it was my usual stupidity. I have this career-long ambivalence towards doing genre films, and I don’t want to sound prissy but there is an element of the genre that could be said to be misogynistic, always carving up girls. There’s a part of me that always asks, ‘How much longer do you want to do this?’”

Dimension turned to George Romero and Sam Raimi. Both passed. So, Dimension kept going further down the list of horror directors, practically weeping while approaching the lesser talents forced on them due to Craven’s refusal to play ball. Still, they dragged their feet because they hoped Craven would change his mind.

Surely, Harvey and Bob Weinstein, the former of whom is one of the biggest sharks in Hollywood history, could strong arm Craven into it.  Not so much, but Bob did pull a neat trick when he informed Craven that Drew Berrymore had expressed in playing the main girl in Scream. That opened a lot of people’s eyes because while Berrymore was not yet the mega-star she’d become she was still a recognized name you wouldn’t expect to see in a horror movie. Her attachment gave Scream an instant boost of credibility and forced Craven to reconsider his stance.

Scream-Wes-Craven-Drew-Barrymore-Behind-The-ScenesStill, even Berrymore was not enough to change Craven’s mind because that did little to assuage his grief over putting out yet more scenes of men carving up women, particularly since the script’s opening scene ended with a poor girl gutted and hung from a tree. In the end, it was actually a nameless young naysayer at a convention who shamed Craven into taking the job, from the mouths of babes and all that.

As Craven told Inside Story:

“A little kid of around 12 came up to me and said, ‘You should do a real goddamn movie again because the movie’s you’ve been doing have been getting softer and softer.’ And that just stuck with me. I thought, ‘Look, you’ve been fighting this your whole career, but the movie’s you’ve made that have really been important have crossed the boundaries of decency and are scary because they are ruthless.’ I called up Bob Weinstein and said, ‘If that job’s still open I’ll take it.’”

Suddenly, the once floundering Scream project had all the momentum in the world with a name actress attached to star and one of the giants of the genre on board to direct. That’s not to say it was all smooth sailing from there. In fact, Berrymore decided just over a month prior to the start of shooting that she no longer wanted to be the main girl but instead the girl who dies in the opening scene, a stroke of genius on her part which worried the producers so much that Craven almost quit. Berrymore was a huge reason why agreed to take the job, and now he was only going to have her for the first 15 minutes of the movie. Luckily, he resisted the urge to quit, and that ended up really working out for everyone, particularly Neve Campbell who happily took the role Berrymore vacated.

Lesson of the day: If you ever see a director/actor in everyday life or at a convention don’t hesitate to tell them what you really think about their recent work because such an unsolicited opinion could directly lead to them making one of the best choices in their career. I guess. Just, you know, don’t be an overly obnoxious jerk about it.

Additional lesson of the day: Wes Craven was a man who knew how to listen to his fans, even when it was a 12-year-old technically too young to have seen any of Craven’s movies.

Source: Inside Story: Scream


  1. I’m sure that a lot of people in Hollywood are used to people telling them that the sun shines from their… A lot of people struggle to deal with any sort of criticism even constructive criticism.

    I’m going to start a list here.

    Imagine if that 12 year old:
    * told Will Smith his movies have sucked hard lately and his son would serve the world better as an accountant => Will Smith returns for Independence Day 2
    * told George Lucas that the Phantom Menace was worse than the Star Wars Holiday Special => Rick “yes man” McCallum is fired. The prequels are better.

    A lot of people write that Michael Bay and Adam Sandler that their films are awful but they are still are profitable. It may be the personal face-to-face honest opinion that makes the difference. On the other hand, Bay and Sandler are rolling in the cash from their rubbish. Money is a hard motivation to go up against.

    1. Michael Bay is an odd case because there have been times where he appeared to apologize for one of his movies in an interview, particularly the second Transformers. However, then he’ll come back and claim that he’d never apologize for any of his work, and that his prior statement was either a misquote or wasn’t intended to upset any fans of the franchise who didn’t see anything wrong with the movie he appeared to throw under the bus. So, at times it seems like Bay is held back from self-critique because based on box office returns he assumes there must be plenty of people who really liked his movie, and he doesn’t want to step on their toes.

      In general, though, I’m sure it’s astonishingly easy for filmmakers and other celebrities to stay within an echo chamber of seemingly positive reinforcement where no one dares tell them what they really think, particularly if the filmmaker/celebrity in question is someone whose immense financial success means they never really have to compromise on anything anymore. Plus, for as much as we fans harp far more on box office totals than ever before so do many of the actors. Will Smith used to be very vocal about wanting his movies to make money, specifically the big ones released in the summer. It’s only in recent years where he’s claimed that’s not his primary focus anymore. Adam Sandler, or one of his frequent collaborators like Dennis Dugan, often deflect any criticism by essentially shouting “Scoreboard!” and pointing to how much money his movies have made, although obviously they haven’t been able to do that nearly as much recently.

      1. Damn it. Film is an art; scoreboards are for sports.

        I also imagine that for every bold and honest 12 year old, there are fans who love their work and groupies. Every sane person hates Nickelback and for every bottle of urine thrown at them at a festival, there’s a dozen groupies.

      2. I have a cousin who loves Nickelback. In fact, they were her first concert. I was always too nice to admit how much I disliked Nickelback. So, I probably wouldn’t be one of those brave souls to tell the Cravens of the world to go make Scream already, dangit. It just seems like impolite, even if we agree that such tough love could likely do a lot for certain Hollywood types.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: