News TV News

Will Time Warner Tear Hulu Down From the Inside?

Before we get into the news of Timer Warner’s potential investment in Hulu I want you to ponder this…

If you’ve ever heard someone joke about how much they hate their Time Warner Cable subscription it’s because TWC is quantifiably the worst at what it does.

Last year, the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) ranked TWC dead last in not just all cable companies but of all companies in the entire Index. Sadly, this was familiar territory for Time Warner. It’s cable division ranked second to last in 2014, and in that same year its internet division received the worst overall ACSI score from any company.

In announcing the 2015 rankings, the ACSI Chairman and founder told, “There was a time when pay TV could get away with discontented users without being penalized by revenue losses from defecting customers, but those days are over. Today people have more alternatives than ever before. Consumer abandonment of pay TV is shaking up the industry and lower satisfaction could mean even more cord cutting by subscribers ahead.”

How is TWC going to redeem itself? Oh, the usual – merge with another company (specifically Charter Communications, pending regulatory approval), threaten to buy out and ruin its competition (kind of).

The problem: Fed up with years of poor service, TWC customers are leaving, either running to rival cable companies or cutting the cord altogether and joining Netflix and Hulu.

The partial solution: Why not just buy a stake in Hulu and ruin it from the inside?

As per The Wall Street Journal (via SlashFilm):

Time Warner believes that the presence of full, current seasons on Hulu—or anywhere else outside the bounds of pay-TV—is harmful to its owners because it contributes to people dropping their pay-TV subscriptions, or “cutting the cord.”

In the discussions about taking a 25% equity stake in Hulu, Time Warner has told the site’s owners that it ultimately wants episodes from current seasons off the service, at least in their existing form, although that is not a condition for its investment, according to the people familiar with the discussions.

Hulu is currently co-owned by Disney, 21st Century Fox and Comcast, and adding Time Warner to that group should ostensibly provide an interesting new wrinkle. As SlashFilm pointed out, this could hypothetically mean that “[Time Warner’s] network HBO would start putting content on Hulu, and Warner Bros. Pictures and Television would start adding more of their movies and TV shows to the streaming service.” However, Time Warner really just wants a seat at the table to potentially take away Hulu’s primary advertising hook, which is that it’s the place to go to see new episodes the day after they air, covering all of the current shows on ABC, NBC, Fox and The CW.

To be fair, TWC isn’t losing nearly as many subscribers as it used to meaning the cord-cutting argument might be overblown. You can also understand the developing perception among the various media conglomerates controlling the Hollywood studios that their deals with Hulu and Netflix have amounted to cutting off their own nose to spite their face. That’s why all of The CW shows, co-owned by Time Warner, might soon leave Netflix and Hulu and transfer over to a CW-specific streaming service, accessible for a small monthly fee. It’s also why the BBC just yanked Doctor Who off of any streaming service in America.

Gone – they’re all gone

That much I get. Something about this story, though, seems so much more insidious. It’s important to remember that WSJ mentioned that Time Warner’s preference to fundamentally alter Hulu’s business model will not actually be something it tries to force through as a conditional element of its proposed purchase of a 25% interest in the company. However, this feels like a move being made by a highly detested company which is desperate to cling to old ways and protect its graying business model. Pull your shows from the service after certain contracts expire, sure, but buying your way into it to tear it down from the inside? Dick move, Time Warner.

Of course, Hulu doesn’t have to accept TW’s investment offer nor does this have to mean that anything will actually change since the other co-owners would theoretically have a say in things. Plus, we are ultimately stressing over thoroughly first-world problems, but, still, dick move, Time Warner.

Source: SlashFilm


  1. Would this dick move even work? People would simply flock to Netflix even more, wouldn’t they? Not to mention that each company is free to create a new streaming service if they want.

    1. Beyond whether or not it would even work, I’m not even sure how feasible it is because I’m not sure how this would work with Hulu’s other co-owners. I could see TW ultimatley pulling all of its shows off of Hulu or forcing a delay where the episodes won’t go up until maybe 3 days after they’ve aired. But that shouldn’t necessarily mean that Disney, Comcast and Fox would do the same thing with their shows.

  2. Seriously? I can’t count the number of shows that my friends and I may have never seen if they weren’t on Netflix, and then followed the current season as it broadcasted, and bought them on DVD when the budget allowed, but they think dealing with Netflix is cutting off their own nose? …in the words of Spock, that is illogical, to the point of stupidity.

    1. I know. I saw the headlines about Netflix losing Doctor Who but assumed that Hulu would still have it. I was wrong. The BBC hasn’t completely explained why they decided to let those contracts expire, but it was pretty well implied that they will finally launch iPlayer in the U.S. which will become the exclusive streaming home for Doctor Who.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: