Legends of Tomorrow TV Reviews

What Have We Learned About Legends of Tomorrow After Its First Five Episodes?

Legends of Tomorrow is the show built out of Arrow and Flash‘s spare parts. The CW loves its DC Comics TV shows, but Ray Palmer, Sara Lance, Firestorm, Hawkgirl and the Central City Rogues can’t all get their own individual spin-offs. So here they are thrown together, turning Legends showrunner Phil Klemmer into the little brother playing with a bunch of hand-me downs from different franchises, banging them together in the air and getting excited when he finds a “We are not so different, you and I” moment for two of characters.

The fifth episode of the show’s inaugural season aired last night. Entitled “Fail-Safe,” it was the conclusion to a surprising two-parter set in 1980s Russia. Next week sees the beginning of a potential run of episodes set in a nightmarish version of 2046 Star City ruled over by Deathstroke and policed by an African-American version of Green Arrow, though old man Oliver Queen will at least put in a token appearance.

I wasn’t crazy about the pilot, but I’ve liked each subsequent episode a little bit more. Even with its sci-fi time travel premise, you can tell this is ultimately of a piece with Arrow, Flash and Supergirl, following the same sincere, but campy impulses. By this point, we’re starting to get a better idea of how Legends show is going to work, and what kinds of relationships its trying to build up:

The Structure

There’s a central mission: stop Vandal Savage. Save the future. Become legends.

How do you tell that story in a 13-episode season when almost none of your characters actually know each other? For starters, you have to find a weekly story structure, as explained by BirthMoviesDeath:

Each episode begins with a big mission involving the entire team, setting up micro-conflicts between them that eventually cause things to go awry, followed by an episode’s worth of branching off into pairs and trios to work out their issues before teaming back up again

The Pairings

legends-of-tomorrow-pilot-part-2-image2-600x400That story structure affords the writers the opportunity to cycle through different character pairings, and thus far it’s been something new every episode:

“The Pilot, Part 1”

  • Carter & Kendra met their son with Rip’s help
  • Leonard, Mick & Sara got into a bar fight
  • Back on the Ship: Ray hung out while Jax argued with Stein

“The Pilot, Part 2”

  • Leonard, Mick & Ray broke into Vandal’s house
  • Jax, Sara & Stein tried to trick Stein’s younger self
  • Back on the Ship: Carter & Kendra trained while Rip sulked

“Blood Ties”

  • Sara, Rip infilitrated Vandal’s weird blood cult
  • Jax, Leonard & Mick pulled a bank robbery and tried to change history
  • Back on the Ship: Ray & Stein did the Fantastic Voyage thing to save Kendra

“White Knights”

  • Leonard & Ray seduced Vandal’s lead scientist
  • Jax, Mick, Rip & Stein fought the Time Agent
  • Back on the Ship: Kendra & Sara trained to master their own self-control issues


  • Mick & Ray bonded in the prison
  • Stein was interrogated on his own
  • Leonard & Sara tried to spring a prison break
  • Back on the Ship: Jax & Kendra lobbied Rip to put them in the game

The writers have learned that Ray is a great comic sidekick with Leonard and Mick. His boy scout quality perfectly rubs up against their criminal inclinations. They’ve deepened the bond between Stein and Jax, an important step since those two were hastily thrown together on The Flash in the first place. Ray and Stein have built up a mutual respect for one another as have Sara and Leonard. As of late, Rip and Sara have grown closer.

dcs-legends-of-tomorrow-photos-from-blood-tiesIf you think of it as a Star Trek crew, Rip is the Captain while Sara and Leonard are constantly vying for First Lieutenant. Stein and Ray are the science officers. Jax is the pilot. Mick is the head of security, and Kendra, um, is the Klingon? I don’t know. They’re still figuring her out now that Carter is gone.

The Drinking Games

Take a drink anytime…

  • Snart delivers a cold-based pun
  • Mick references his love for stealing stuff and fighting
  • Stein and Jax bicker
  • Kendra references how only just a couple of weeks ago she was a barrista who didn’t know anything about Egypitan warrior priestesses or ancient curses.
  • Sara looks sad and talks about her blood lust
  • Rip Hunter melodramatically turns and declares something about the fate of the world resting on their shoulders.
  • Rip shows someone on the team video of what their city will look like in the future if they don’t complete their mission-of-the-week.
  • The people being left out of the weekly mission protest, “What about us?

The Budget

The budget is reportedly high by CW standards, but  it’s still low enough that across five episodes we’ve only been in two primary time periods (1975 and 1986). It’s a time travel show, sure, but it has to be a cost-effective one. Are you crazy? They can’t afford new period-specific clothes every week.

They Keep Killing Vandal Savage

If we have hear to one more freakin’ story about some historical figure Vandal happens to have met in his long life…

It’s taken a moment to adjust to the notion of a season-long big bad who does die, just not for good what with the whole immortality thing. We’ve seen Vandal die two or three times now, but to him death is but a minor flesh wound.

They’re Constantly Cleaning Up Their Own Messes

In the rush to defeat Savage, Rip didn’t realize the gift he was giving his sworn enemy by introducing him to an Ant-Man/Iron Man suit, a man who can fly and shoot fire and two criminals with the coolest freeze ray and flamethrower you could ask for. As a result, our legends aren’t so much fighting Savage yet as they are constantly racing to take away that potential world ending weapon they accidentally gave him.

Time Travel Makes for Better Cameos

Cisco was on this week’s episode, not as himself but as a drug-induced vision. They could have done something more interesting with that. Next week’s episode with Oliver Queen stepping into the more classic comic book version of the Green Arrow with the beard is a better use of the show’s time travel premise and placement in the Arrow/Flash universe.

Just Think of It As the TARDIS Translation Matrix

Matt Smith and the Tardis from "The 11th Hour"Doctor Who‘s aliens all happen to speak English and understand everything the Doctor and his companions say because the TARDIS is translating everything for them.

Last week, Legends introduced its version of that. Everyone simply swallow pills which attach to their vocal cords, and the ship’s computer auto-translates their speech into whatever language they want. How exactly that enables them to also hear local Russians as if they were actually speaking in English I don’t know, but just go with it.

Rip Lies Sometimesarthur-darvill-doctor-who-sera-rip-hunter-spi-L-V4wD_RFine. They’re not actually considered legends in the future. And, sure, this isn’t the first time he’s traveled back in time to stop Savage. But, seriously, that’s it. That’s the end of his lies. Complete honesty from this point forward, right?


FilmSchoolRejects argued, “I can’t figure out yet if this show is good, or simply entertaining. But the answer to that question doesn’t matter much because the first few episodes have just been so much fun.” I’m of a similar mindset, although I hesitate to differentiate between “good” and “entertaining.” This show, like Arrow, Flash and Supergirl, is basically sincere camp. It’s not for everyone, and it has its flaws. However, it’s improving from week to week, seemingly with each new compelling character pairing they try out. You can still play a drinking game along with its various tropes, a cold pun here, a melodramatic Rip Hunter turn there, but it’s not necessary to enjoy what is turning into Arrow and Flash‘s crazy little brother.


  1. Yes, I think the show is a lot of fun. It’s also fascinating to watch the show improve episode by episode. You can see the creators tweaking the formula to get it just right, which is also part of the fun.

    1. Legends is still easy to mock. In fact, that might be part of its appeal, but it is getting progressively better. As you said, they keep tweaking their formula, and from the looks of next week’s trailer we might get our first episode where no one stays behind on the ship to work through their personal issues, if they’re actually doing anything at all.

      1. I kinda like those stay behind and argue on the ship scenes. 😊 The fight between Jax and Stein was very moving for me and I enjoyed it. I immediately hated Stein until made his motivations clear, then I got it.

        The show is also getting better at characterization, little by little. In fact it seems to be improving on whatever I complained about the week before.

      2. “In fact it seems to be improving on whatever I complained about the week before”

        Same here. I also have nothing against the stay behind on the ship scenes. I am just curious to see if they will stray from that formula next week.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: