To live is to know regret and to live long means learning from that regret. That might sound especially bleak, but few if any of us ever get to know a perfect existence. So, until Elon Musk invents time travel or that YouTube time traveler shares his secrets the only way forward is, well, forward. However, it’s easier than ever before to simply stay stuck in neutral, technically living your life without actually engaging with it or learning from your regrets. If only the universe could slap us in the face and force us to change.
Actually, there’s a trope for that: the “Groundhog Day Loop.” Just like its namesake movie, the “Loop” almost always involves someone reliving events on repeat until they ultimately learn how to solve a problem and/or become a better person thus negating the underlying cause of their mysterious time travel conundrum. According to TVTropes, this particularly storytelling device has appeared in nearly 30 movies and over 60 different TV shows, a bigger-than-you’d-think portion of them coming in just the past decade.
Deja vu – again
The trope is now so prevalent it will have appeared in two major pieces of pop culture within mere weeks of one another: Last weekend, it was Russian Doll, Netflix’s breakout series about a misanthropic video game programmer named Nadia (played to career-best perfection by Natasha Lyonne) reliving the events of her 36th birthday party over and over again; next weekend, it will be Happy Death Day 2 U, the sequel to Blumhouse’s horror hit which continues to be sold as “Groundhog Day as a slasher.”
Underscoring how familiar this has become is the following: As I was collecting my thoughts about Russian Doll and preparing this article I paused to finally binge the first season of Star Trek: Discovery. Guess what happens in the 7th episode, the whimsically titled “Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad”?
And you know what? It’s the best damn episode of the season to that point.
To some, such a weird clustering of Groundhog Day knock-offs would seem like just the latest piece of evidence in the larger argument that Hollywood has run out of ideas. Which, sure. Only three of last year’s top 20 movies can be categorized as original or at least not a sequel/reboot/remake. However, not all sequels/reboots are bad and not all Groundhog Day knock-offs are wholly unoriginal. Some of them know just how to build off of everything Groundhog Day did right and add at least something new to the mix.
The time loop as a slasher
For example, in using the familiar time loop storytelling structure, the Happy Death Day films cleverly invert genre norms by allowing a girl who starts out seeming like the stereotypical slasher movie’s selfish, bitchy, unlikable “slut” evolve into being a multi-layer, compelling, and completely lovable final girl. As Jessica Rothe’s delightful puts it in the trailer for the sequel, “Now I’m living the better version of my life .”
What can the sequel do with that? Finally, answer what actually caused the loop in the first place. Say, does her college’s campus have some kind of experimental particle accelerator? Can’t wait to find out.
The time loop as a Netflix dramedy
Russian Doll, meanwhile, joins The Good Place and Amazon’s Forever in using the TV comedy format as a Trojan horse for philosophical and existential musings. Yes, its basic structure is heavily indebted to Groundhog Day, but it’s also an of-the-moment kind of show, clearly crafted by people – co-creators Natasha Lyonne, Leslye Headland, Amy Poehler, and an all-female writing staff – who understand the way the most bingable Netflix properties work:
Use a perfectly designed mystery to hook the audience. (What’s causing the time loop?) Make sure every episode has a cliffhanger or game-changing revelation. (Spoiler: What do you mean Nadia isn’t the only one stuck in this loop? And what’s all this business with her having some kind of past trauma with her mom?) Maybe even place some of those big moments at the start of an episode instead of at the end just to keep the audience from settling too easily into your rhythms.
Do that right and even the most resistant audience member might end up having binged four episodes in one sitting without even realizing it or totally meaning to. They just have to see what Nadia will do next, what gender norms she’ll continue to defy or suffer under, what self-destructive behavior she’ll continue to indulge until she finally doesn’t, and how this particular mystery ends.
Others will care less about that and more about the show’s quietly profound message about our responsibility to each other and need to engage with the world. As Wired passionately argued:
[Russian Doll]’s a perfect polished gem, a pure-hearted spacetime meditation that has more in common with Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind than Groundhog Day. It’s about love and betrayal and forgiveness and gentrification. It’s recursive and affecting in ways Black Mirror: Bandersnatch wishes it could be.
The mystery element is played up to such a degree as the show goes on, however, that some have been left disappointed with an ending that provides no concrete answers. If you’ve seen Groundhog Day you really shouldn’t be surprised. The “why” rarely ever truly matters in such stories; it’s about what the characters learn from the experience.
Luckily in the case of Russian Doll, watching Nadia and [again, spoiler for anyone who hasn’t made it to episode 4] her fellow traveler grow into better human beings more responsive to those around them makes for a perfectly cathartic finale. “What I want is for one person to feel a little less alone, and a little bit like they’re OK and it’s OK and you can keep showing up to fight another day,” Lyonne told The Hollywood Reporter on how to interpret her existential adventure.
The time loop done right
There are going to be those Happy Death Day and Russian Doll holdouts who continue to resist because once you’ve seen one “Groundhog Day Loop” you’ve seen them all. “Time loop episodes are too often viewed as just an exercise in box-ticking, or a fun gimmick with little consequence in terms of plot development,” Alasdair Stuart argued on Tor.com last year. He’s not wrong. It can just be a lazy trope rolled out because a filmmaker or TV showrunner recognizes an easily exploited formula.
However, there’s something universally appealing about time travel to anyone who has ever wondered “what if?” about their life and placement in the world. Time loops get to do all of that while also functioning as fascinating character studies that also reward rewatch because don’t you want to pick up on the little hints you missed along the way? Russian Doll, in particular, has a LOT of that.
Plus, I’m always a sucker for a time loop montage of characters just throwing caution to the wind and leaning into the fun of the situation.
As I said at the start, to live is to know regret. I meant that in relation to the bigger things in life, but if you watch Russian Doll, that won’t add to your list of regrets. I promise.
I just love seeing a time loop story come together. What about you? If you have watched Russian Doll at this point, what did you think? Let me know in the comments.